Instagram Wants You to Shout
Thoughts on Instagram: hot takes and rage baits, book discourse, and the exhaustion of trying to be seen online.
I started my Bookstagram account (a book account on Instagram) two years ago. I was unemployed (still am) and needed to contribute to something other than household chores. I wanted to create something and be acknowledged and praised for it. I expected to make something of my account, small or big, though, no need to lie, I wanted to be big. Looking back, I see how stupid I was because I had no idea how these platforms worked. I had only spent time on Facebook when it first came out (I was in high school), and on Twitter only when something was going on in the world (before Musk). My university roommate opened my first Instagram account for me because she found it so weird that I didn’t have one. All of that was years ago, and even though I know how much these platforms and their algorithms have changed, it turned out I didn’t know know.
The hot takes and rage baits have always been there, I guess. But I swear to you, there was very little of it at first. I was sharing my book reviews, finding new indie authors, making book lists to share my favorites. People were reading my thoughts and engaging in meaningful ways. I felt like people were getting to know me (in a book sense) and genuinely cared about my takes. There were discussions about race, representation, and who gets to tell which stories; of course there were, because literature, culture, and politics are all intertwined. I didn’t expect or want a sterile environment. The problem is, if you write something nuanced and thoughtful, five people see it. Nuanced and thoughtful do not mean watering down your ideas or being neutral. You can hold your ground, be outspoken while still being reasonable, but that is not what IG wants either. What it wants is something reactionary, something that shouts, then it will show you to five thousand people. We are only human, and when we spend time putting something out there, we want people to see it.
Here is what your feed looks like as a result:
Reels that start with “I didn’t read the book, but [insert some culture war issue here]” How can you have an opinion, dude? Context matters, and in this context, the context is the whole book.
People are reacting to something that is not even there. Like, collectively, people are arguing against something someone supposedly said, even though no one can find where they said it.
The words “problematic,” “racist,” and “misogynist” appear in every other post, to the point that they have no meaning anymore. This is a disservice to a very real problem. These things exist, with real consequences for individuals and communities. What we are doing on social media gives us the illusion that we are tackling this problem, but we are not. We are changing no one’s minds.
A year later, I started to hate my time there. Was I going to spin my posts to please the algorithm gods? But you know, even if you do that, it is not enough: you need to post constantly, and I don't have many worthy thoughts to put out there, nor the will or the discipline.
Not every account that got big was running psychological operations on you, but they posted a lot and they engaged, engaged, engaged. I don't think I have ever hated a word like that.